Defender
Volke Aeno

Gender: Male
Location: Georgia, United States
Birthday: May 4, 1992
Join date: January 15, 2009
Posts: 1454
View full profile
Send a private message

Signature

Recent posts

#1454
May 15 at 5:11 PM
SOTW #99 - Disney
Quote (originally posted by NiteNinja):
Anything created by Disney can be used.


With this, I think there's some inconsistencies. Under this criteria...

-Studio Ghibli should be excluded since Disney neither owns nor makes these. They do localizations only. The inclusion of this baffled me the most.
-Kingdom Hearts should be included since they're created from a collaboration between Disney and Square Enix.
-Certain things with Star Wars should be included based on Disney's Star Tours attraction at various Disney parks.
-I don't know about Marvel's case.

If you exclude partial work, then everything but Disney Animation Studios and arguably Pixar is out.
#1453
May 15 at 4:51 PM
SOTW #99 - Disney
Quote (originally posted by Bonnibel):
Everything that isn't Disney should be excluded.


That's a difficult line to draw, hence why I'm asking for clarification.

Is "Disney" defined as loosely as "anything they worked on/own", or as defined as strictly as "Disney Animation Studios ONLY"? They seem to draw the line somewhere in the middle and don't make it clear what defines that line in a general sense.
#1452
May 15 at 4:29 PM
SOTW #99 - Disney
Quote (originally posted by NiteNinja):
Well volke, for starters, the star wars films for disney have not been made yet, so who knows what the storyline will even be. Marvel, I didn't even know Disney made that.


First off, that only covers 2 things. What I'm really wanting to know is how you guys separate

Star Wars/Marvel/Kingdom Hearts
from
Pixar/Ghibli

I'm wanting all of these to be accounted for. What criteria makes one Disney as opposed to not Disney? A generalized rule would be more effective than lists, because you've completely left things like Indiana Jones unaccounted for (also owned by Disney now).