A. Gunman
Cluttered with effects that are majorly distracting. Border is stupid. Should be smaller imo. Too distracting. Text is too ugh...
B. Inrai
Colors are wack. BG is wack. Sig is Too big for focal making other things draw attention away from it.
C. iLink
Too long and text doesn't need to be there. Lighting could be better.
D. Saiga
Text is bad and it freaks me out in a bad way.
E. Hentekorino
Lighting could be better, text more visible with some depth added to it. Render looks a bit LQ. Sorta like this one. It's meh.
F. BlazeDrag414
BG is bad, the lighting isn't going in the same direction, text is bad and misplaced, what ever effect is going on, on the render is bad imo.
G. Hichez
What's up with the vector brushes on the BG. It sort of clashes with what's going on in the foreground. The motion blur isn't necessary imo opinion. I also see something going on in the background on the right side of the sig that looks like it doesn't belong.
H. BF
I spot some filter abuse. I honestly have nothing to say about it besides that. Bad text of course.
I. ColdDegree
Text is bad, C4Ds placement are bad. Render looks LQ.
J. Lawliel
I see a lot of bubbly effects. Nice colors. The text isn't bad, but a bit faraway. Way to many effects on the sig though. Clear up the foreground some.
K. Zerosyko
I get the concept behind it. Not as well executed as you probably intended it to be. Decent depth but LQ. Text color bothers me btw.
L. Doromac
Just badly executed.
M. Piffy
I don't know. Right side could be cropped some. Lines on the black part of BG could go. The grey stuff in the BG can go as well.
N. Princessdaisy09
A lot of unnecessary effects there. Me no likey nothing. Itabadtransparentsig.
O. heytallman
Hey dude. What is this?
You are worth something btw.
P. Fatalishunta
Overly bright. Too much wrong.
Q. Player 4
I hate this mostly because of Meta (jk).
Gradient layer is meh. Text is bad. Needs more effects or more negative space imo.
R. Chirp
bad text. Red gradient layer is not koo. I've seen his rendered used too many times for me to like it...
S. Skippy
Read some tuts.
nuff said
T. UVAJosh
I really can't make out what that is. Something from Star Wars maybe?Nice smudging. Clipping mask isn't working. Use better lighting.
U. Demon Kirby
Eh. Very simple. Don't like small vertical dimensions though.