THE OFFICIAL JUDGING TOPIC: HALLOWEEN

Subscribe to this topic.

Topic

Page: 1 2
#21
4:29 PM Oct 26 2010 2010
LEGOF
Profile Illuminator
Joined: Apr 2009
LEGOF rooted for the $208,097,414 New York Yankees 2009 championship team.LEGOF keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.LEGOF participated in the Karaoke Contest!

-Darkf0x-'s profile.
*Theme:
The theme was "Scary stuff&some kingdom hearts." I don't get scared easily and I wasn't from his profile. 18/20

*Style:
It's very messy. Jumbled up pile of pictures with no real sense of order. I'm not a big fan of copy/paste with absolutely no order. 5/20

*Effort: He got many pictures but didn't bother to try to organize or balance anything out. The different sized pictures/gifs are an eyesore. 6/20

*Creativity: Copy/paste isn't very creative. 5/20

*Satisfaction: Meh. 7/20
Total: 41/100

FWamane's profile.
*Theme: The theme was "Ghosts." It's broad, so I'll be expecting a lot. 18/20

*Style: Copy/paste for the most part. There is some organization and originality but not much. 13/20

*Effort:
Personal picture? Nice. That will add some more points. Widgets were utilized. 18/20

*Creativity:
The picture can't save you from everything. There are many more ghosts he could have used other than those from video games. This will spike it down some. 12/20

*Satisfaction:
It's decent. 15/20
Total: 76/100

kangurocow's profile.
*Theme: The theme was "The legend of zelda/pkmn." Broad theme that I've seen a lot now. 17/20

*Style: Not many pictures. They were great, but the only Pokemon picture seemed out of place. The widgets are utilized. Not enough content in my eyes and the content that was there wasn't all that great. 14/20

*Effort: There's not much effort shown. 14/20

*Creativity: It's not very creative. 14/20

*Satisfaction: It was a little below average. It wasn't terrible but there wasn't anything there to make it good. 15/20
Total: 74/100

Yami No Suisei's profile.
*Theme:
The theme was "Orange and black with a hint of creepy." Both the profile and theme fit Halloween. 19/20

*Style: No sense of order. There are some links to eerie music but other than that it's disorganized. Not everything matched Black/Orange or with a hint of creepiness. 15/20

*Effort: A little bit above average on the effort. Excellent use of the widgets and font but lacking on the picture content. 16/20

*Creativity: The use of widgets and font was creative but not everything matched in the About Me section. 15/20

*Satisfaction: A little bit above average. The About Me section was lacking and the widgets were made the meat and potatoes. 14/20
Total: 79/100
Last edited by LEGOF, 5:35 PM on Oct 28, 2010
#22
10:16 PM Oct 26 2010 2010
Miles of SmashWiki
Smash PhD
Joined: Mar 2009
Miles of SmashWiki watched the unlikely run of the 2011 St. Louis Cardinals culminate in the happiest of flights.Miles of SmashWiki did something funny.Miles of SmashWiki impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Miles of SmashWiki helped a member with a problem.Miles of SmashWiki keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.

LEGOF

*Theme: Amalgam of themes takes you down a few, I'm afraid. 13/20
*Style: Eh.... 8/20
*Effort: Short, but the music helped some. 8/20
*Creativity: Some. (Expect this for "Creativity" a lot.) 11/20
*Satisfaction: A tad. 12/20
TOTAL: 52/100

SMASH

*Theme: Mario Halloween. I see the Mario... where's the Halloween? 2/20
*Style: Um. No Halloween-y content at all really. 1/20
*Effort: Did he forget about this? 0/20
*Creativity: ... 2/20
*Satisfaction: Zilch. 0/20
TOTAL: 5/100

VickiIcarusChan

*Theme: Pogeymanz. Eh. 16/20
*Style: Well-laid out for the most part. 16/20
*Effort: It's there. 16/20
*Creativity: Somewhat. 16/20
*Satisfaction: Pretty well done I suppose. 17/20
TOTAL: 81/100

Fire!

*Theme: Zombies. Not the most original but very applicable. 17/20
*Style: Extremely well-executed, including usage of shoutouts (misspelled but whatever) and other things. 20/20
*Effort: High. 20/20
*Creativity: Much. 18/20
*Satisfaction: An excellent entry by one of last year's runner-ups. 20/20
TOTAL: 95/100

Megatron1

*Theme: Forgetting the contest. 1/20
*Style: 0/20
*Effort: 0/20
*Creativity: 0/20
*Satisfaction: 0/20
TOTAL: 1/100

Awesomeguy1

*Theme: Zelda monsters. Cleaves close to the Halloween theme, especially with choice of monsters. 18/20
*Style: Cleanly laid out with symmetry, plus appropriate avi+widgets+cards. 19/20
*Effort: Seems like some good work went in here to balance the profile out. 18/20
*Creativity: Maybe not the most original theme but well-done. 17/20
*Satisfaction: Nice work. 18/20
TOTAL: 90/100

peterspookysaurous

*Theme: Haunted house. Nice choice. 17/20
*Style: Quite effective. 18/20
*Effort: It's there in loads. 18/20
*Creativity: High level of it. 18/20
*Satisfaction: Expected a little more (maybe too much?) but well done. 17/20
TOTAL: 88/100

RaffiX

*Theme: Anime. It works, I guess. 17/20
*Style: Seems a tad jumbled but the pics themselves are good. 15/20
*Effort: Some. 15/20
*Creativity: Hard to see much of it... 11/20
*Satisfaction: Mostly well done. 16/20
TOTAL: 74/100

Kwiz

*Theme: Connects the Cartoon Network show characters to Halloween very adeptly. 19/20
*Style: Usage of the rest of the profile (widgets+cards+shoutouts+avi) plus a clear Halloweeny feel scores you high here, but the About

Me pics feel a tiny bit disorganized. 19/20
*Effort: Looks well done to me. 19/20
*Creativity: Rather original subtheme, and pulls it off pretty well. 17/20
*Satisfaction: Mostly pretty good. 17/20
TOTAL: 91/100

Pokemon_Fan

*Theme: Yes Pokemon... no Halloween? 2/20
*Style: Aside from Dialga avatar, I see nothing for this contest. 1/20
*Effort: 1/20
*Creativity: 1/20
*Satisfaction: 0/20
TOTAL: 5/100

MIMI

*Theme: Demonic Darlings. Nice choice of subtheme. 19/20
*Style: Only used the About Me+avi, though she did so quite well. 17/20
*Effort: Above average. 16/20
*Creativity: Some. 15/20
*Satisfaction: Felt a little short, but what was there was good. 16/20
TOTAL: 83/100

Eminem

*Theme: Choice of theme was Eminem+M&M=pun=points. 19/20
*Style: Not so well-laid out, however. 9/20
*Effort: Plus a tad short. 9/20
*Creativity: Decent but not enough to judge on. 12/20
*Satisfaction: Had great potential from the theme but wasn't very well-executed. 11/20
TOTAL: 60/100

ven

*Theme: Generic Halloween-y stuff. Didn't have much of a specific subtheme, so I had to keep a low-ish score here. 11/20
*Style: Used much of the profile well, but seemed rather nebulous on the idea of sticking to a subtheme. 14/20
*Effort: A tad sloppy in places (like a loose bracket in About Me) but mostly pretty well-laid out. 15/20
*Creativity: Mildly creative. 12/20
*Satisfaction: Some. 13/20
TOTAL: 65/100

Surreal

*Theme: Kingdom Hearts. K. 17/20
*Style: What did Forest Maze have to do with this (besides "getting lost" in it)? 14/20
*Effort: A tad short, good sir. 8/20
*Creativity: Some. 11/20
*Satisfaction: Hmmm. 12/20
TOTAL: 62/100

Miles of Night and Shadow

As much as I love my own work of profiley art.... I can't judge myself. Skipped.

Black Star - Pavel

*Theme: Nintendo/Anime. Feels like two themes... but otherwise pretty good. 15/20
*Style: Relevant video links plus effective usage of profile. 20/20
*Effort: Looks like there was a lot of it. 19/20
*Creativity: Pretty generic theme(s), but well-executed. 17/20
*Satisfaction: High. 19/20
TOTAL: 90/100

Rukirawrz

*Theme: Sonicky. Halloweeny. It works. 18/20
*Style: Images feel well-matched. Pretty effective. 17/20
*Effort: Images seem well-organized mainly. 18/20
*Creativity: Some. 17/20
*Satisfaction: Not a Sonic fan myself, but this was well done. 19/20
TOTAL: 89/100

Dsora

*Theme: Dry Bones+King Boo+Grim Reaper. Nice choices, but down a tad for multitheming. 14/20
*Style: Pretty well-done. 17/20
*Effort: Clearly present. 16/20
*Creativity: Good. 16/20
*Satisfaction: Quality first entry. 18/20
TOTAL: 81/100

-Deity_LP-

*Theme: Also Sonicky. Also Halloweeny. Familiar? 18/20
*Style: Pretty well-done thought short. 15/20
*Effort: Rather short. 8/20
*Creativity: Some. 17/20
*Satisfaction: I think Rukirawrz's was a better Sonic/Halloween entry, though this isn't bad. 15/20
TOTAL: 73/100

Jack the Ripper

*Theme: Scary story. Well-chosen, and you're perhaps the only user with such a textual emphasis. 20/20
*Style: Clearly works the media chosen well. 18/20
*Effort: Short but packs a big punch anyway. 14/20
*Creativity: Did you write this? 18/20
*Satisfaction: Short but very effective. Nice job. 18/20
TOTAL: 88/100

Fubuki

*Theme: It said "tales of tricks and treats" in the entry but I can't see a clear theme other than images feeling Halloweeny. 3/20
*Style: Mixed. 16/20
*Effort: Clearly more than a little. 17/20
*Creativity: Some. 16/20
*Satisfaction: I still don't get the theme ._. 12/20
TOTAL: 64/100

-Blackpuff-

*Theme: Additional Pogeymanz. 16/20
*Style: Nice poem, but that's most of the content. 15/20
*Effort: Recognizable. 15/20
*Creativity: Hmmm. 14/20
*Satisfaction: Sure. 14/20
TOTAL: 74/100

Princess Fantaisa

*Theme: Further Pogeymanz. 16/20
*Style: Meh. 14/20
*Effort: Some. 16/20
*Creativity: Some. 14/20
*Satisfaction: I guess it's well-enough done, though no real "wow" moments. 13/20
TOTAL: 73/100

Arban

*Theme: I'm sorry, did you say Pokemon? 16/20
*Style: Good usage of whole profile. 17/20
*Effort: A tiny bit short but effective. 16/20
*Creativity: Mild. 14/20
*Satisfaction: I like it. 18/20
TOTAL: 81/100

Sumer

*Theme: Anime/cute...? Ok... 18/20
*Style: Well-executed. 18/20
*Effort: Lengthy and well-laid out. 20/20
*Creativity: Present. 19/20
*Satisfaction: Pretty impressive work, I suppose. 17/20
TOTAL: 92/100

-HachiStar64-

*Theme: Silly/anime. Huh. 17/20.
*Style: Feels a tad mixed, but mostly clear. 17/20
*Effort: That broken pic is a shame, but otherwise good. 17/20
*Creativity: Hard to tell. 10/20
*Satisfaction: Meh. 12/20
TOTAL: 73/100

-Darkf0x-

*Theme: Mighty generic in "scary stuff+". 6/20
*Style: Clear attempt to go for the skin-peeling stuff, which I guess is well-done. 17/20
*Effort: Pretty good, though why are the Pokemon things left in there? 15/20
*Creativity: Slight amount. 7/20
*Satisfaction: Not to my style, but decent work. 13/20
TOTAL: 58/100

FWamane

*Theme: Ghosts. I guess that works. 11/20
*Style: Meh. 13/20
*Effort: Some. 13/20
*Creativity: Some. 13/20
*Satisfaction: I dunno. Nothing really "wowed" me here. 14/20
TOTAL: 64/100

Kangurocow

*Theme: Zelda+Poke. Ok... 13/20
*Style: Neutral. 12/20
*Effort: Very short. 8/20
*Creativity: Somewhat present. 9/20
*Satisfaction: Nothing jumped out here either. Sorry. 14/20
TOTAL: 56/100

Yami No Suisei

*Theme: Orange+black fits the theme. 15/20
*Style: Color theming works well and is well-executed mostly. 18/20
*Effort: Clearly. 16/20
*Creativity: Decent. 14/20
*Satisfaction: You cannot grasp the true form of this profile. 15/20
TOTAL: 78/100

Link14

*Theme: *tsktsk* for multitheming. 14/20
*Style: Meh. 14/20
*Effort: There's some. 14/20
*Creativity: Meh again. 13/20
*Satisfaction: Not bad, but no "wow" factor. 14/20
TOTAL: 69/100

zae26

*Theme: Reaper poem and matching pics. Nice choice. 19/20
*Style: Clear and elaborate. 18/20
*Effort: Evident. 18/20
*Creativity: Original choice to go with the poem. 18/20
*Satisfaction: Si me gusta. 18/20
TOTAL: 91/100

Swordbeam

*Theme: Pokemon + anime. Multitheming: -2. 14/20
*Style: The little "divider" lines are a nice touch. 16/20
*Effort: Some. 15/20
*Creativity: Mild. 14/20
*Satisfaction: Some. 13/20
TOTAL: 72/100

princessdaisy09

*Theme: I have no idea even after rereading your post. 3/20
*Style: ... 7/20
*Effort: Short. 7/20
*Creativity: Minimal. 4/20
*Satisfaction: Barely present. 7/20
TOTAL: 28/100

Torisho

*Theme: Kids+candy... feels generic, ya know? 14/20
*Style: Not bad, but... short. 14/20
*Effort: Very short. 4/20
*Creativity: Some, I suppose. 11/20
*Satisfaction: Minimal. Next time, maybe try giving me more to judge? 7/20
TOTAL: 50/100

Albino Kirby

*Theme: Those black & white pics? ... 15/20
*Style: Feels a little lacking. 12/20
*Effort: Also lacking. 12/20
*Creativity: Somewhat. 13/20
*Satisfaction: Meh. 13/20
TOTAL: 65/100

Leeling

*Theme: Apple Apocalypse. Fruit zombies is quite the originality. 20/20
*Style: Original art earns full merit here, I think. 20/20
*Effort: Drawings seem a tad rushed, but otherwise good. 18/20
*Creativity: Highly creative. 19/20
*Satisfaction: A strong showing by the previous event's champion. 19/20
TOTAL: 96/100

Asami

*Theme: Oh. Pokemon. 16/20
*Style: Clear and to the point. 17/20
*Effort: Lengthy and consistent. 18/20
*Creativity: Some. 14/20
*Satisfaction: Most extensive Pokeprofile. 18/20
TOTAL: 83/100

Kakashi of the Skulls

*Theme: Skeletal etc. 17/20
*Style: Effective. 15/20
*Effort: Some. 14/20
*Creativity: Some. 16/20
*Satisfaction: Some... >_> 13/20
TOTAL: 75/100





THERE'S MY SCORES. Oy.


Srsbsns is always lurking (ﺒ_ﺒ)
Quote (originally posted by nealdt):
You'll always be first in my heart, Miles.
Last edited by Miles of SmashWiki, 11:06 PM on Oct 26, 2010
#23
11:32 PM Oct 26 2010 2010
Peterchristmasaurous
Moderator
Joined: Mar 2009
Peterchristmasaurous is a moderator.Peterchristmasaurous has provided valuable testing services for the website.Peterchristmasaurous wrote an exemplary guide.Peterchristmasaurous did something funny.Peterchristmasaurous helped a member with a problem.Peterchristmasaurous keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.Peterchristmasaurous participated in the Karaoke Contest!


"Megatron1

*Theme: Forgetting the contest. 1/20"

XD miles XD
#24
5:06 PM Oct 27 2010 2010
Miles of SmashWiki
Smash PhD
Joined: Mar 2009
Miles of SmashWiki watched the unlikely run of the 2011 St. Louis Cardinals culminate in the happiest of flights.Miles of SmashWiki did something funny.Miles of SmashWiki impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Miles of SmashWiki helped a member with a problem.Miles of SmashWiki keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.

:/
#25
8:41 PM Oct 27 2010 2010
Dashing Professor Beef
Honorably Discharged
Joined: Aug 2008
Dashing Professor Beef is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.Dashing Professor Beef did something funny.Dashing Professor Beef impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Dashing Professor Beef keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.Dashing Professor Beef wrote an exemplary guide.Dashing Professor Beef has an eye for classic game sprites and a head for modern gaming's legacy.

Link14
*Theme: Zelda and anime halloween. (12)
*Style: This person managed to find some halloween images, but didn't manage to do anything special with them or the widgets. (8)
*Effort: Doesn't seem like too much work went into this. (9)
*Creativity: Not much. (7)
*Satisfaction: Very, very boring. (4)
40/100


zae26
*Theme: A poem involving grim reapers. Very odd, but nice choice. (15)
*Style: Very organized images that work well with the poem he is using. The widgets are organized very nicely and have a nice pattern with them. I wouldn't have had Hidan in the end there personally, but it's still a great job. (16)
*Effort: While the reaper images are fairly plain, he did a good job with the widgets and the image/poem layout. (13)
*Creativity: A refreshing change of pace from all of the other themes. He didn't try to go overboard with his choice of topic, which was a fantastic decision. (15)
*Satisfaction: I greatly enjoyed this. Much much better than what I was expecting. (16)
75/100


Swordbeam
*Theme: Another pokemon/anime halloween choice. (13)
*Style: The widgets are mostly the same color, which is fine. The profile itself was much shorter than I was hoping for. The images were generic, sure, but the little halloween banner in between them was kinda cute. Oh well. (12)
*Effort: Doesn't seem like a lot of work went into this, if the length is any indication. (9)
*Creativity: It's anime/pokemon halloween, so I wasn't expecting much creativity. But the pictures were nice, at least. (11)
*Satisfaction: It wasn't bad, but it wasn't spectacular either. (12)
57/100

Torisho
*Theme: Kids and candy. If that's not halloween, I don't know what is. (18)
*Style: Unfortunately, the profile itself is greatly underwhelming. Two pictures (not including the banners), no widget interaction that I can see, and...well, that's it. (6)
*Effort: As bare-bones as the profile images are, they're at least great-looking. I only wish there was more. (12)
*Creativity: The choice of topic had a lot of potential here, but it seems to have been wasted. (10)
*Satisfaction: I like the images. I like the topic choice. I don't like how little there is, however. (10)
56/100


Albino Kirby
*Theme: Scary stories. Good choice. (14)
*Style: When I see the topic of "scary stories," I expect to see some words. Instead, all I was treated to were a few images of ghosts(?) and some video with Wario in it. (6)
*Effort: icon_neutral (6)
*Creativity: Failed opportunity here. (4)
*Satisfaction: I'm not a fan of bait and switch, and this profile is the definition of it. (5)
35/100


Leeling
*Theme: Campfire stories which include an apple apocalypse. (13)
*Style: Just one image, but it's the crux of her entire theme topic. Hilarious, to boot. I wish something could've been done with the widgets, but there's not really a whole lot you can do with those and a story. (14)
*Effort: Amazing comic, but nothing else on the profile, really. (15)
*Creativity: Another great leeling comic, and a fantastically weird story! (15)
*Satisfaction: The comic itself was awesome. The profile could've used more, though/ (13)
70/100


Asami
*Theme: Halloween pokemon images. (13)
*Style: If the games section was supposed to be related to the theme, I didn't see it. The profile itself was nothing but a loooooong list of halloween-related images. It got pretty boring after a while. (11)
*Effort: It doesn't seem like much effort went into this outside of using GIS. (8)
*Creativity: Not much here. (6)
*Satisfaction: I wasn't expecting much, and I got exactly what I (apparently) wanted. [b](5)
43/100
Last edited by Dashing Professor Beef, 6:51 PM on Oct 29, 2010
#26
4:46 PM Oct 28 2010 2010
LEGOF
Profile Illuminator
Joined: Apr 2009
LEGOF rooted for the $208,097,414 New York Yankees 2009 championship team.LEGOF keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.LEGOF participated in the Karaoke Contest!

Link14's profile.
*Theme: The theme was "Zelda Halloween/Anime Halloween." I'm getting tired of these anime-themed profiles. Yes, including mine. 14/20
*Style:
Copy/paste with little organization. Uses widgets a bit for Link's purpose. 14/20

*Effort:
Copy/paste and little effort on the widgets. 13/20

*Creativity:
Copy/paste. 10/20

*Satisfaction:
Decent profile, I guess. I'm going harsher now. 14/20
Total: 51/100

zae26's profile.

*Theme:
The theme was "Scary Reapers - Poem." Great look to the profile. 20/20

*Style:
Good organizing and colors. 20/20

*Effort:
Clearly there is effort. Great effort. 19/20

*Creativity:
Clearly there is creativity. Great creativity. It matches the skin perfectly. 20/20

*Satisfaction:
One of the better profiles and I really liked it. This is probably the only profile that really grabs what I think of when I hear Halloween. 20/20
Total: 99/100

Swordbeam's profile.

*Theme:
The theme was "Anime and Pokemon." Another one... >.> 13/20

*Style:
Organized with a cute little divider. Sadly, there's not much content. 18/20

*Effort:
Above average effort. 18/20

*Creativity:
Three pictures divided nicely. That can only go so far. 18/20

*Satisfaction:
Good feel overall. 18/20
Total: 85/100


princessdaisy09's profile.
*Theme:
The theme was "i tried to scare you,but i failed v.v." A relevant theme but not so relevant pictures. I guess she was right when she said she failed. 16/20

*Style:
Copy/paste. No organization whatsoever. 12/20

*Effort:
Copy/paste. No effort to organize whatsoever. 12/20

*Creativity:
Copy/paste. No creativity in organizing whatsoever. 12/20

*Satisfaction:
Another copy/paste. 12/20
Total: 64/100


Torisho's profile.
*Theme:
The theme was "Kids and their candy." Very relevant to Halloween yet very short-lived. 17/20

*Style:
Looks like 1-2 pictures organized very neatly. +1 for loli. 18/20

*Effort:
Great effort for what's there. Bad effort compared to everyone else. 14/20

*Creativity:
There's not much once you think about it. It's a funny pun, however. 15/20

*Satisfaction:
It was funny and cute but there's not enough. 12/20
Total: 76/100

Albino Kirby's profile.

*Theme:
The theme was "Scary stories to read in the dark." OK theme. 16/20

*Style: Copy/paste. No sense of organization. 8/20

*Effort: There's a MALR video down there. 10/20

*Creativity: Copy/paste. 7/20

*Satisfaction: I wasn't. Sympathy won't come to me again to raise this score. 9/20
Total: 50/100

Leeling's profile.
*Theme: The theme was "Campfire Stories to Tell at the Campfire:  Apple Apocalypse." I've seen some good reviews and counting that she was the winner of last year's competition, I will be judging harder on her profile. The profile matches the theme. 20/20

*Style: A humorous, creative comic strip. Very stylish in my opinion. Other than that, nothing else was utilized to match Halloween or her theme. 19/20

*Effort: I see lots of effort in that comic strip. Other than that, nothing else was utilized to match Halloween or her theme. A little disappointing to see from last year's winner. 16/20

*Creativity: The comic is very creative. Her art style made me laugh in my head. 20/20

*Satisfaction: It was a great comic but I really wanted to see more. I came in with very high expectations but not all of them were met. 18/20
Total: 93/100

Asami's profile.
*Theme:
The theme was "Spooky/Pocket Monsters." I gotta give some credit for taking the extra time to type out Pocket Monsters but that won't affect the score. It's very relevant to Halloween and so is the profile. 20/20

*Style:
Copy/paste but with little organization. 16/20

*Effort:
Decent effort. 14/20

*Creativity:
Eh, it's kinda creative. 17/20

*Satisfaction:
At least it wasn't hard on the eyes. 13/20
Total: 80/100

Kakashi Of The Skull's profile.
*Theme: The theme was "Horrific Halloween." If that and the profile don't say Halloween then I don't know what does. 20/20

*Style: Copy/paste. Good creepy pictures, however. 17/20

*Effort:
Copy paste with no organization. 7/20

*Creativity: The theme is creative compared to all the Anime/Link/Sonic profiles I've seen but the profile isn't. 10/20

*Satisfaction: +2 for being one of the few profiles that went hardcore Halloween. I'm despise Edgar Allen Poe but I won't let that drop any points since it relates to Halloween so well. 14/20
Total: 68/100
Last edited by LEGOF, 10:52 PM on Oct 29, 2010
#27
6:38 PM Oct 28 2010 2010
Peterchristmasaurous
Moderator
Joined: Mar 2009
Peterchristmasaurous is a moderator.Peterchristmasaurous has provided valuable testing services for the website.Peterchristmasaurous wrote an exemplary guide.Peterchristmasaurous did something funny.Peterchristmasaurous helped a member with a problem.Peterchristmasaurous keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.Peterchristmasaurous participated in the Karaoke Contest!

"*Theme: Pokemon halloween. Seems to be a very OU theme (HA, GET IT!?)."

LMAO just noticed that beef, im liking these puns by the judges
#28
4:15 AM Oct 31 2010 2010
jarvitz
Staff Slayer
Joined: Dec 2008
jarvitz is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.jarvitz did something funny.jarvitz impressed a staff member by doing something smart.jarvitz helped a member with a problem.jarvitz keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.jarvitz has referred new users to the site.jarvitz wrote an exemplary guide.jarvitz won a Screenshot of the Week Contest!jarvitz won a Custom Texture Contest! jarvitz participated in the Karaoke Contest!jarvitz defeated the site's Pokémon League Champion in a Pokémon battle!jarvitz overcame every obstacle and bested the site's Pokémon League with the unlikeliest of teams!jarvitz holds or held a world record score in one of Smash's Stadium modes.

Before Anyone sees these I think I judge very nicely.

LEGOF

*Theme: Mario Bros., Lucky Star and other spooky things. A little bit too broad but still good. 16/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: He seems to have put a lot into it. I think something spookier could have been found in some places. 16/20
*Creativity: I like how the boos and the Lucky Star characters (sorry I don't know their names) were combined together. The song didn't really fit when I was looking at the middle of the large picture. 17/20
*Satisfaction: Overall it is very nice. I really dislike the Jigglypuff in for melee especially with that skin. It just doesn't go. 17/20
Total: 81/100

SMASH

*Theme:Mario Halloween. It has the Mario part. It doesn't have much of the rest. 10/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 4/20
*Effort: There could have been a lot more effort made. 5/20
*Creativity: It was a sample theme. None at all. 0/20
*Satisfaction: As much as I like Mario, this disappointed me. Orange skin probably would have made it look better. 3/20
*Total: 22/100

VickiIcarusChan

*Themeicon_biggrinark/Ghost-type and cute "dress-up" Pokemon Halloween style. The theme was mostly followed and it relates to halloween quite nicely. It is not completely specific, as in it has more than one thing. 17/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 18/20
*Effort: It seems to have a lot of effort put into it.A few things could have changed. 17/20
*Creativity: The idea could have been a little bit more creative then just pokemon. 17/20
*Satisfaction: Overall Very nice in my eyes. 17/20
*Total: 86/100

Fire!

*Theme: Zombie Apocalypse. This is amazing. Great job. Almost everything has to deal with the theme. The brawl and melee widgets are off but besides that it is nice. 19/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 18/20
*Effort: You could have done something better. I won't say what (yet). 19/20
*Creativity: Very unique idea. I really like it. 20/20
*Satisfaction: I personally love it. Nice job. You spelled dead wrong. http://i629.photobucket.com/albums/uu15/jarvitz/firetypo.jpg?t=1288484650 19/20
*Total: 95/100

Megatron1

*Theme: Sonic as the Grim Reaper. Forgot about the contest. -2/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. -2/20
*Effort: -2/20
*Creativity: -2/20
*Satisfaction: -2/20
*Total: -10/100 (yes those are negatives)

Awesomeguy1

*Theme: LoZ monster Halloween. I like the theme. Zelda has always been a good game. 16/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 18/20
*Effort: I see a lot of effort put forth. There is almost nothing not zeldafied. 19/20
*Creativity: Nice idea. A good way to blend the zelda games together. Some more could have been done with the shadow temple from OoT. 17/20
*Satisfaction: I'm not really a fan of what the redeads are doing to link. 18/20
*Total: 88/100

peterdinosaurous/peterspookysaurous

*Theme: trapped in a haunted house. It doesn't completely fit the theme in my eyes. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 14/20
*Effort: More areas of the profile could have been edited. 12/20
*Creativity: I dislike the idea in general. Im not that type of person. It is also a fairly generic haunted house, maybe a little worse. 15/20
*Satisfaction: I have said this, I don't really like it. 12 /20
*Total: 67/100

Raffix

*Theme: Anime Halloween. Followed the theme. Not a very specific theme at all. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 14/20
*Effort: It seems to just be a bunch of girl pictures from anime's thrown together 14/20
*Creativity: Not that original. Not very creative but still decent. 16/20
*Satisfaction: I dislike how much is showing in a couple of the pictures as a guy who doesn't watch that stuff. 15/20
*Total: 73/100

kwiz

*Theme: Old cartoon network shows. Not a completely specific theme. It still follows the theme though. 17/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 13/20
*Effort: There could have been more in this department 12/20
*Creativity: I like the uniqueness of it. 17/20
*Satisfaction: It could have been better. 15/20
*Total: 74/100

Pokemon_Fan

*Theme: Pokemon Halloween. There is pokemon but there isn't much if any halloween 3/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 0/20
*Effort: 1/20
*Creativity: 0/20
*Satisfaction: 0/20
*Total: 4/100

MIMI

*Themeicon_biggrinemonic Darlings. Its on the theme but there isn't very much. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: Not very much was changed. I feel more could have been put into it. 14/20
*Creativity: Its unique and an ok idea. 16/20
*Satisfaction: I have no clue what the theme is. I guess I just don't know everything. That made me not like it as much. 12/20
*Total: 73/100

eminem

*Theme: scary eminem's and M&M's. It follows the theme, but not entirely. 13/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 12/20
*Effort: I feel more of the profile could have been edited. 13/20
*Creativity: Its a scarier version of a haunted house. So it is not too original or anything. 12/20
*Satisfaction: I really dislike the overall bloodiness of it and the violence. This is still a community website. 8/20
*Total: 58/100

ven

*Theme:anime halloween / Ghost / Masked figures / skulls / mask / candy / pumpkins. The theme is very general. You could have just said “halloween” and it would have gotten about the same score.11/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 12/20
*Effort: I see a lot of effort, but more could have been put in. 16/20
*Creativity: I like how you blended all of those themes. I still dislike the more than one theme though. 17/20
*Satisfaction: It was a very interesting profile to go over. 17/20
*Total: 73/100

surreal

*Theme: Kingdom Hearts... fresh from the chest. The only part of the profile that was really edited to the theme was the about me section. The music also didn't follow the theme. 13/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: I fell a lot more effort could have been put in. 15/20
*Creativity: Its a nice idea and fairly creative. I know you could have been a little bit more creative then just some pictures. 14/20
*Satisfaction: I have never really played kingdom hearts so that takes it down a little bit in my eyes. I also wasn't satisfied with the amount of decorating there was. 13/20
*Total: 70/100

Miles of Night and Shadow

*Theme: I haven't seen any themes of just a color yet. Everything follows the theme. 19/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 18/20
*Effort: It seems like a lot of effort was put in. Each picture links to a different song. 18/20
*Creativity: Its just a color. Its not the most original thing ever. 14/20
*Satisfaction: I like the song used for the wire frames. 16/20
*Total: 85/100

Black Star - Pavel

*Theme: Nintendo/Anime themed Halloween. The theme needs to be more specific. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: A lot of effort seems to have been put in. Nice job. 18/20
*Creativity: Like I said not the best of themes. Still fairly creative. 15/20
*Satisfaction: I really liked looking at this profile. 17/20
*Total: 80/100

Rukirawrz

*Theme:Sonic and friends. Almost everything fits. Its really good. 18/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry.17/20
*Effort: A good amount of effort was put in. 16/20
*Creativity: Very creative. Nice idea. Love the pictures. 19/20
*Satisfaction: I was very pleased by this. Good work. 19/20
*Total: 89/100

Dsora

*Theme: Dry Bones and King Boo/Reaper. The theme needs to be one thing. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: It seems to have some effort. It could use more. 14/20
*Creativity: It is kind of creative but not very. 14/20
*Satisfaction: I think it was just ok. 14/20
*Total: 72/100

-Deity_lp-

*Theme: Sonic characters. Some of the profile fits the theme. Not everything does. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 14/20
*Effort: A lot more effort could have been put in 12/20
*Creativity: It wasn't the most creative but it was still not horrible. 13/20
*Satisfaction: I didn't really like it that much 12/20
*Total: 65/100

Jack The Ripper

*Theme:Creepy-ish. It followed the theme. 17/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: You could have done more with the rest of your profile. 14/20
*Creativity: It wasn't creative in the fact that is was just “creepy” but they way you did it was. 16/20
*Satisfaction: This style doesn't really fir my personal liking. I get scared easily. 13/20
*Total: 75/100

Fubuki

*Theme: tales of tricks and treats. It needs a specific theme. Where were the tails? 8/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 13/20
*Effort: More could have been seen. 15/20
*Creativity: Very Generic. Little to none. 6/20
*Satisfaction: I disliked this quite a bit. 10/20
*Total: 52/100

-Blackpuff-

*Theme: Gengar/Halloween Ghosts. Where are the other halloween ghosts? Its very short. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: Needs much more effort. 13/20
*Creativity: Not the most creative. Many people think of ghosts and halloween. 12/20
*Satisfaction: This wasn't the best profile out there. 10/20
*Total: 65/100

princess fantaisa

*Themeicon_razzokemon Halloween. Nothing there. 0/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. -1/20
*Effort: -4/20
*Creativity: -1/20
*Satisfaction: -4/20
*Total: -10/100

Arban

*Theme: Pokemon Halloween. Almost everything has to deal with the theme. 18/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 19/20
*Effort: A lot of planning was put into this. It is one of the more thought out profiles. 19/20
*Creativity: Very creative. I love the way it flows. That joker picture is just amazing. The only thing is that pokemon is a semi-generic topic. 18/20
*Satisfaction: This profile was very pleasing to look at. 19/20
*Total: 93/100

Sumer

*Theme: Anime/Cute The theme needs to be more specific. It's so general. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: It seems like a lot of effort was inserted. 16/20
*Creativity: Not the most creative. I do like what was done with the widgets. 17/20
*Satisfaction: I am not a perv so I really didn't like it too much. Its just me. 15/20
*Total: 77/100

-HachiStar64-

*Theme: anime/silly halloween stuff. General theme 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: It was average 15/20
*Creativity: Not the most creative theme ever. The pics were a bit creative. 14/20
*Satisfaction: Not the greatest. 15/20
*Total: 74/100

-Darkf0x-

*Theme: Scary stuff&some kingdom hearts. nothing -2/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. -2/20
*Effort: -2/20
*Creativity: -2/20
*Satisfaction: -2/20
*Total: -10/100

FWamane

*Theme: Ghosts. Mostly fits the theme but not completely. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: I could have seen some more. 15/20
*Creativity: Fairly creative. Ghosts are usually connected with halloween though. 12/20
*Satisfaction: Not the best in my opinion. 12/20
*Total: 70/100

kangurocow

*Theme: The legend of zelda/pkmn. It needs one specific theme. It was followed fairly nicely. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: there could have been some more in certain areas. 15/20
*Creativity: Nice. Unique. 16/20
*Satisfaction: I really like the pic with majora's mask on it. 17/20
*Total: 79/100

Yami No Suisei

*Theme: Orange and black with a hint of creepy. It didn't really fit the theme much. 10/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 10/20
*Effort: Needs major improvement 8/20
*Creativity: Not good at all. Very generic 8/20
*Satisfaction: Didn't like it. 10/20
*Total: 46/100

Rinku14

*Theme: Zelda Halloween/Anime Halloween. Needs one specific theme. 14/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: Good effort. 17/20
*Creativity: Not very creative on the anime end. 12/20
*Satisfaction: Im not a big fan of it. Some parts were good but not all 10/20
*Total: 69/100

zae26

*Theme: Poem. Nice. Was on the theme. You could have said reaper poem or something. 17/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 18/20
*Effort: Was greatly thought out. 17/20
*Creativity: very creative and original with a poem. 18/20
*Satisfaction: I really liked it. 16/20
*Total: 86/100

Swordbeam

*Theme: Anime and Pokemon. It was mostly on the theme although short. The theme itself wasn't great 13/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 17/20
*Effort: A good amount of effort was put in. 16/20
*Creativity: Anime isn't that creative 15/20
*Satisfaction: Not the greatest in my opinion. 14/20
*Total: 75/100

princessdaisy09

*Theme: i tried to scare you,but i failed v.v. Doesn't fit the theme at all. 3/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 4/20
*Effort: Little to none. 5/20
*Creativity: little to none 5/20
*Satisfaction: bad 5/20
*Total: 22/100

Torisho

*Theme:Kids and their candy. On the theme, but short. 13/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 12/20
*Effort: Needs improvement here. 9/20
*Creativity: more needed. Not a creative theme. 9/20
*Satisfaction: Not really feeling it. 12/20
*Total: 55/100

Albino Kirby

*Theme:Scary stories to read in the dark. It fits the theme. 16/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry.16/20
*Effort: Could have seen a little more. 15/20
*Creativity: Very creative. Needs more details on each one. 14/20
*Satisfaction: Not a fan of that kind of thing. 12/20
*Total: 73/100

Leeling

*Theme: Campfire Stories to Tell at the Campfire: Apple Apocalypse. On the theme. Maybe edit other parts of the profile? 17/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: It looks handmade and time consuming. Still more with the rest of the profile. 18/20
*Creativity: made yourself and such18/20
*Satisfaction: I liked it. 16/20
*Total: 85/100

Asami

*Theme: Spooky/Pocket Monsters. It needs a more specific theme. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 15/20
*Effort: It seems to have taken a while. 16/20
*Creativity: It was ok, not the greatest. 16/20
*Satisfaction: I liked it overall 16/20
*Total: 78/100

Kakashi Of The Skulls (KotS)

*Theme:Horrific Halloween. It fits the theme, but it is a simple theme. 15/20
*Style: I don't really know how to comment on this category. This may change later if not then sorry. 16/20
*Effort: Seems to have at least some effort in it. 14/20
*Creativity: Fairly uncreative with the category and everywhere else. 13/20
*Satisfaction: I don't personally like those types of pictures. 10/20
*Total: 68/100
#29
4:39 PM Oct 31 2010 2010
Miles of SmashWiki
Smash PhD
Joined: Mar 2009
Miles of SmashWiki watched the unlikely run of the 2011 St. Louis Cardinals culminate in the happiest of flights.Miles of SmashWiki did something funny.Miles of SmashWiki impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Miles of SmashWiki helped a member with a problem.Miles of SmashWiki keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.



For those wondering why the averages for myself, peter and LEGOF have a little green mark, it's because ours were calculated by a different formula (divided by 4 instead of 5 because we didn't judge ourselves).

Congratulations to our top finishers!
Page: 1 2
 
Quick Jump
rss