45:55 MK, we have grab releases, chain and needles go through nado, and get in his face and we can do some damage, but it isn't even, we're easily gimped by him so yeah
40:60 Snake He can pull nades out for like everything lol, makes it annoying
Diddy 45:55 I like to use his bananas against him since Sheik is fast enough to actually use them decently. Close range diddy has more limited options imo.

Alrighty Good job guys the board is officially complete!!! Check the main page for a new topic which is my surprise as promised!
Once BBR puts up a new MU thread this coming December i will update this as well and make some nice design and finish the in construction section and hopefully ill have some ideas to add to this =)
Next discussion: Anything look wrong on that list? If you have a mu you would like to rediscuss let us know and why!

Wait, how is MK's total ratio 45:55 when three people thought 40:60 or worse?

oops typo. Thanks for the catch

Oh yeah, as for whether you want to use zeik/shelda or not, here are my discrepancies from what has been stated in the OP:

Peach: solo sheik imo
Kirby: solo sheik, I'm not sure if Zelda does better in the MU since Kirby looks like he gimps zelda about the same as he would sheik and juggles her about as hard.
Luigi: solo sheik
Bowser: either one works tbh, I like sheik more because I like having sheik's gimp game and her kill moves actually do surprisingly ok v. bowser. I can see Zelda being used as well though
Captain falcon: Definitely Sheik, our ftilt lock is really solid on c. falcon, and we have some good edgeguard tools. I don't like C falcon getting into my space, which I feel he'd do more often v. Zelda, Sheik at least fights pretty even w/ him in close quarters

Snake I feel atm is also an either way, I see Earth do fairly well with both (although it's been awhile since Earth has used Sheik in general lol), but I personally prefer sheik, Zelda feels very vulnerable in the MU.

Does anyone else feel there are differences to how they personally approach whether to use solo sheik or Zelda/Sheik together?

I'm not really a fan of using Zelda, I used to love it, but it's just so annoying for me. I like to camp, and to approach also, but putting Zelda into the mix kinda screws up my playstyle. If I'm Zelda though, it's basically "What is approach?"

Yeah, exactly! I also feel like I have some sort of threat to offset how badly I get juggled as sheik. With Zelda, when you get unrooted, you usually stay that way for awhile lol.

The MUs I usually use her for are D3, ROB (mainly because it's easy to shieldpoke him with smashes if you don't let him recharge his shield after one, it's a weird but interesting gimmick to make killing easier), DK sometimes (for the same reason as ROB), and occasionally Bowser.

For Pika/ICs, I don't like the MU with either char lol, I usually just stick to Lucario/Snake, my other chars.

Sorry for the complete lack of activity guys, loads of school work with finals week. Again, I'll catch up.

I see what you did thar.

man I need help with luigi, I got 7/25th at a recent tourney, but lost a mm to someone's Luigi. I hear the best strat is to camp your balls off, but I also want to know if it's possible to use a smart aggressive playstyle to stop him, problem is he just needs one dthrow or utilt on me to do some massive damage, and he kills very early

I play Luigi Alot, let's friendly ill teach u it

Might have to call a raincheck on that, wifi lag is something I'm not really used to lol.