Well here we go ColdDegree:
Well let's see... Very very... Bland. It sure looks nifty, but what did you really do to it? It seems like you took an image of a griffin you found wherever then pasted a worn papery effect over the top. Then erased the parts around the griffin. The text might have been better off left out. I don't know 3/10; Put more effort into it next time. I hate saying this (even though I say it often) but look up some tuts.
Royer:
Interesting. I really don't see you around, Royer. But I like the fact that you're contributing. Now for the critique. Firstly, it's too big. Normally with Sprites you want to limit your tags' size, but you seem to have done the maximum. Next there seems to be a lot cuttering over your focal, even a few things obstructing it. There's also the text, it's not bad, but neither is it good. You probably could have made the word "Pegasus" a bit smaller and moved it and ".CRY" over to the other side of Pegasus. 5/10
Gunman:
To start; that border is terrible. It's just bad. You really don't need to put borders on everything you make and if you do use borders don't make them so big and... whatever else you do to them. Inside the border is almost equally bad. The text placement is a no-no, never ever shove text into a corner. The text itself is also pretty bad. When I look at your sig the first thing I see is the ridiculously big and ugly text. Text will grab attention no matter how big or ugly it is, so you want to incorporate it into your tags to help the flow of the piece. Now what should be the focal, Kratos. The smudging around him and whatever it is he's fighting is mediocre at best. The rest... I can't really comment on because the text takes up to much damn space. 2/10
zSlider:
This is a great entry. I really like a lot about this one. The C4Ds blend effortlessly into the flow of the tag and add a beautiful effect. This tag is an example of better text placement. There isn't really any depth but I feel this tag didn't need to achieve any to begin with. One of the two things I do not like is the flame, I just don't like it. The other thing I don't like is the slightly off white background. 8/10
traveling cat:
Hrm... Interesting. Your entries always have their own style, I like that. I value uniquity in almost all things. But I don't actually like the style (no offense). Again with the borders, oh the borders ((Suck it Barnes and Noble)). The sort of rounded border/background thing you have going is not by any means needed. I think the whole sig should've been made differently. There isn't any flow just Cerberus on a background with large text that says "Cerberus". It just doesn't have much going for it. This looks more like a button or link on a website than a sig. 3/10
Doromac:
Oooh, pretty colors. Okay I really like the light blue/pink color thing you have going, it's really nice/easy to look at. The C4D placement could have been a bit better, but it still works fairly well. The blue bit on his eye seems unnecessary and I can't stop hating it, it should have been placed on soft light or something to make it blend a bit more with the rest of his face. if it was already then it might have been better off not included. 8/10
GBrute45:
Funny that we would have two entries this week with the same render. I suppose it does look cool. This sig is similar to ColdDegree's in the sense that it really doesn't have much going on in it and that it would look better without the text. You probably should have done some other stuff with it. A few more effects here and there etc. etc. 6/10
SuperHero:
Sorry, Fang, but it's bad. I would have done something else.
Zerosyko:
Well it's very... monotone. That's always interesting. Too monotonous to be honest. You should have used more color really. Again the text placement is bad and since you have no color it would have been better to leave the text out. The border is completely unnecassary and looks bad. 4/10
Doromac has my vote though.