A: Ayoub:


Nice color and the text. But what the hell is retro about this?
The flow is all over the place, and the sun glasses are distracting.

I still can't get past the fact that there's nothing retro about it :/


B: Sumer


Everything is bad. The flow, the color, the text, the render, the quality. All of it. Anddd it's not retro.

C: Player 4


Bleh

D: Arban


It's boring and still not retro. Since when did they have GBCs in the 50s, 60s, or 70s?
The simplistic style is nice, but it's still boring. The whole left side could be cut off and you wouldn't miss much. The GB needs more blending into the back ground to give it better dept. It could really use more color as well, and given the name is GB COLOR, it would have been a nice touch. The light is pretty bad as well, and the text is generic.


E: heytallman



I love floyd, and it's nice to see something that's actually retro. Though it's pretty cluttered, and the bricks draw me off because they seem crooked. Text could be better as well.

You improving though, and that's what counts.

F: Eklipse; aka: Nickee Coco



Again it's nice seeing some follow to the criteria. I don't like seeing the logo twice, it's very distracting. Lighting could be better as well. The colors are nice but there's something about the pastels that throws me off.

G: U.V.A.josh


It's boring. The random colored specs are bad, the lighting is bad too. The text is ok. It really needs more color, especially if you're going to add the little color that you did.
I'm also missing the part where this is retro. I mean I guess robots are retro, but it's not really what I would think when I think retro.



H: Dorobro


Nice subject of choice . Lighting is nice as well. I really don't like the skulls, they're too distracting and too in focus for where they are. I mean I like the idea that you're going for, but it gets more attention then your main focal. The main focal seems pretty LQ as well. The squares are a nice touch but the one being smaller then the other two also throws off the flow of it.

I: Jonn


I like the lighting and colors but that's about it. I've never been a fan of sprite sigs, and you went overboard with all the sprites you used. All the sprites look like they were just pasted on top of the BG and you were done.

I'm still failing to see what is actually retro about this, 90s gaming isn't retro.


J: Revenant


Lol Rev's sigs are always the best, it's never fair competing with you.
I love the colors, the subject of choice, and the floral design is a very nice touch.
The lighting throws me a little, it looks good but it seems to be missing something I can't quite put my finger on it.
I'm also not a big fan of the filter on Bruce, but it works with what you have. I really like the splatters as well.
Good ****

Retro isn`t specifically 50-70`s, people. A 90`s signature can still be considered Retro, but Rev said exactly; "try and think of something 50-70s". Doesn`t mean it`s a necessity.