Quote (originally posted by
Dr. Robotnik):
not to bash or anything, but im a graphic designer, so i know good stuff when i see it. it seems like this didnt take long to make. i could do it in a hour. ive seen a lot of good sigs that looked like they took more work than this.
i say, hold a t-shirt design contest so we can get the best possible design for a shirt as possible. although i like the simpleness of this design, a lot more could be done to make this look quite a bit better.
...ummm, there was one. The fact that there is a winner and multiple submissions shows us that there already WAS a T-Shirt design contest that was open to the public. In fact, it was announced several times on the front page. If you or anyone else KNOW that they can do something better, then quit b*tching about it and MAKE AN ENTRY NEXT TIME.
Milktea made an entry, it was simple, it was clean, it was relevant...it won. She deserves Congratulations for her efforts and thanks for the work she put into it. Maybe it would take YOU an hour, but did you ever consider that it might take people who AREN'T graphic art designers longer? And she certainly doesn't deserve all of these "...are you serious? her design won?" , or "I could have done better " comments..that's just rude and you have to realize how insulting that is to her and to the people judging the contest.
You guys don't like the decision, hey that's fine...you're entitled to an opinion, but you're NOT entitled to throw that opinion around flimsily on a friendly sight without considering who you might be hurting. If you had a problem with the judging, take it up with the judges in a more tactful manner then posting hate comments all over the Home page article.
Last edited by
Cobra, 10:25 AM on Jul 29, 2008