Quote (originally posted by
Mood4food77):
the eagles problems lied all with vick, he threw 4 ints and fumbled the ball away once
the eagles live and die by michael vick
but the giants stunk it up against the cowboys, Eli was slightly off but the rest of the offense sucked, victor cruz dropped a few passes, nicks couldn't get open for his life, bennet played well but not well enough, the o-line sucked so the running game couldn't get going
and the defense was the same as last year, great d-line, everything else couldn't muster up enough help
eli played well enough to win, romo just played quite a bit better
You obviously didn't read any recaps or read ANY pundits' takes on the game.
Yeah, Vick threw four picks. He deserves a good portion of the blame (not all of it like you insist). But then, I need to ask you: it's obvious Vick played poorly. But the Eagles have LeSean McCoy, a top 3 RB in the NFL. The Browns' pass defense was top 5 last year, but their run defense was next to last. Why didn't the Eagles run the ball more? Shouldn't Andy Reid be smart enough to realize that the pass game isn't working and that Shady should be running the ball more? He should, but he didn't do it. This is something that drives Eagles fans crazy: his inability to adjust during the game. This is why Tom Coughlin is a great coach and Andy Reid isn't: Coughlin adjusted his style in the first Super Bowl win by lightening up. Then last year, he adjusted the playcalling: the Giants couldn't run the ball, so he gave the ball to Eli, told him "Go crazy", and the Giants became the absolute best big-play team in the league. Andy Reid is too stubborn to deviate from his plan and his scheme.
Pundits recapping the game pointed out how poorly the Eagles' gameplan was. Not to mention how the offensive line sucked. But for you, it's all BLAME MICHAEL VICK VICK SUCKS VICK SUCKS BLAME VICK. You need to learn to look a little deeper into things and look at the entirety of the game rather than jump to the simplest conclusion, because football is a WAY deeper game than that. Passing the ball 72% against one of the best pass defenses and not using your elite RB is a bad idea. Yeah, Vick deserves to be blasted. But for God's sake place SOME blame on Andy Reid and Marty Mornheinweig for concocting such an ill-conceived gameplan and not utilizing one of the team's best weapons.
And trust me, if the Eagles don't make the playoffs (which they won't), both Andy Reid and Michael Vick will be gone. Vick may cost the Eagles the postseason, but Andy will be just as responsible.
Last edited by
Queensryche, 11:11 PM on Sep 10, 2012