Banning Planking - Very crappy rule.

Subscribe to this topic.

Topic

Page: 1 · 5 6 7 8 9 · 12
#121
10:15 AM Jun 8 2009 2009
Darknid
Got Lucky
Joined: Jan 2009
Darknid impressed a staff member by doing something smart.

diem has a point, planking is a bit redonk and MKs like him can easily abuse it
#122
11:47 AM Jun 8 2009 2009
.Nails.
Smell the Ladies Love
Joined: Aug 2008
.Nails. regularly contributes to the All is Brawl Stadium community.

Quote (originally posted by Darknid):
diem has a point, planking is a bit redonk and MKs like him can easily abuse it


I agree, it's unquestionably abusable by atleast MK, but what's the best solution?



#123
4:40 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
tehf1r3
Popular
Joined: Feb 2009

Quote (originally posted by .Nails.):
I agree, it's unquestionably abusable by atleast MK, but what's the best solution?

Picking up a character who can deal with it. Which is only 10 chars though. And only one of them seems to do well against MK.
Official solution: Pick up snake
#124
4:51 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
Darknid
Got Lucky
Joined: Jan 2009
Darknid impressed a staff member by doing something smart.

Quote (originally posted by tehf1r3):
Picking up a character who can deal with it. Which is only 10 chars though. And only one of them seems to do well against MK.
Official solution: Pick up snake


yeahhh next thing you know, some character will be able to infinite everyone except jiggz

well the only solution is to pick up jiggz

now you must learn snake and jiggz in addition to your main and secondary otherwise you will get raped

then for some reason you must learn ROB, then sheik, then pit

it's bs.

ban planking
http://www.formspring.me/darknid

#125
5:02 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
dmbrandon
Not my Vice-President
Joined: Mar 2008
dmbrandon passed a Tournament Host Certification test.dmbrandon rooted the Green Bay Packers to their fourth Super Bowl win, Favre or no Favre.dmbrandon did something funny.dmbrandon impressed a staff member by doing something smart.dmbrandon is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.dmbrandon is actually a guy pretending to be a girl.dmbrandon wrote a blog entry that was featured on the All is Brawl front page!

NO CHARACTER CAN BEAT PLANKING. PLEASE PAY ATTENTION.
#126
5:06 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
Mood4food77
Baller
Joined: Mar 2008
Mood4food77 did something funny.Mood4food77 impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Mood4food77 is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.

not even pikachu?
#127
5:14 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
.Nails.
Smell the Ladies Love
Joined: Aug 2008
.Nails. regularly contributes to the All is Brawl Stadium community.

5 characters, maybe, can deal with planking well. You shouldn't have to pick one of those characters, though, to have a chance at winning.



#128
5:20 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
Spellman
His Love is a Precious Island in a Tumultuous Sea
Joined: Mar 2008
Spellman is so totally righteous.Spellman will put a spell on you.Spellman made significant contributions to all areas of All is Brawl!Spellman did something funny.Spellman impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Spellman helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.Spellman won an All is Brawl Signature of the Week contest!

And this isn't news or anything, but remember, this is the tactic that you're protecting. Correct me if I'm wrong, but even the characters that have a slim chance of dealing with it are at a severe disadvantage.

A solution was found. That gives enough leeway for some strategic planking, and not so much that it's going to be how the match is decided. It's an easy, enforceable rule that doesn't leave room for error.
Bomp.
#129
5:35 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
LoF pwii
Unstoppable
Joined: Jul 2008
LoF pwii did something funny.LoF pwii is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.

planking shouldn't be banned, I mean it's anoyying butim sure there's a way to fight it
#130
5:38 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
TheRealBobMan
Joined: Oct 2008
TheRealBobMan is an All is Brawl moderator.TheRealBobMan has written an exemplary guide on the All is Brawl forum.TheRealBobMan did something funny.TheRealBobMan impressed a staff member by doing something smart.TheRealBobMan helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.TheRealBobMan is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.TheRealBobMan wrote a blog entry that was featured on the All is Brawl front page!

Brawl needs some sort of negative penalty like Guilty Gear. You spent too long avoiding conflict, all of your moves go fully stale.
#131
5:40 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
Hichez
Signature Artist
Joined: Jun 2008
Hichez impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Hichez helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.Hichez won an All is Brawl Signature of the Week contest!

nah thats not necessary if we were to ban planking. Plus just dont approach your opponent if they are planking they want you to approach thats the mind game.
#132
5:50 PM Jun 8 2009 2009
Umbre
Transcendent Priority
Joined: May 2008
Umbre is an All is Brawl super moderator.Umbre has provided valuable testing services for the All is Brawl website.Umbre creates imbalance with the power of the sword.Umbre keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.Umbre positively represents All is Brawl and actively brings new users to the site.Umbre has written an exemplary guide on the All is Brawl forum.Umbre made significant contributions to all areas of All is Brawl!Umbre did something funny.Umbre impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Umbre helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.Umbre is a member of the evil league of evil. The fly in your soup. The pebble in your shoe. The demon in your bed. The peel on which you slip. A pin in every hip. The fear that keeps you awake. And your tears are all the pay I'll ever need.Umbre regularly contributes to the All is Brawl Stadium community.

Planking is not a mindgame.
Mario Kart Wii: ιm Umbre
Mario Kart 7: HD★Umbre
#133
12:12 AM Jun 9 2009 2009
Clockw0rk
Best on My Block
Joined: Mar 2008
Clockw0rk is a troll. Please ignore anything said by this user.

lol brawl already has so many outrageous rules to already make this game "competitive" whats one more dumb one gonna hurt?
Quote (originally posted by Trail):
No apology is necessary, asians are a hive mind race. So in essence, you actually did speak to both Ray Chung and Peterson Chen.
#134
12:35 AM Jun 9 2009 2009
Hichez
Signature Artist
Joined: Jun 2008
Hichez impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Hichez helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.Hichez won an All is Brawl Signature of the Week contest!

Quote (originally posted by UmbreonMonarchy):
Planking is not a mindgame.

you technically could classify anything as a mindgame.

#135
1:01 AM Jun 9 2009 2009
Rain that cool Zoner
Spread the Love
Joined: Feb 2009

Quote (originally posted by hichez):
nah thats not necessary if we were to ban planking. Plus just dont approach your opponent if they are planking they want you to approach thats the mind game.
Lmao planking isn't a mindgame. Planking is when you have the stock/percent advantage and you go to a side of the stage and abuse the invincibility frames to keep yourself in the lead until the timer runs out. The only reason it is being debated is because it's not classified as stalling (which is banned)
#136
12:52 PM Jun 9 2009 2009
dmbrandon
Not my Vice-President
Joined: Mar 2008
dmbrandon passed a Tournament Host Certification test.dmbrandon rooted the Green Bay Packers to their fourth Super Bowl win, Favre or no Favre.dmbrandon did something funny.dmbrandon impressed a staff member by doing something smart.dmbrandon is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.dmbrandon is actually a guy pretending to be a girl.dmbrandon wrote a blog entry that was featured on the All is Brawl front page!

P_Wii, I know you're going to Viridian City tourney. Me and you, 5$ mm with planking on.
#137
1:10 PM Jun 9 2009 2009
Darknid
Got Lucky
Joined: Jan 2009
Darknid impressed a staff member by doing something smart.

diem is gonna make like $3,000 getting planking banned
#138
1:12 PM Jun 9 2009 2009
dmbrandon
Not my Vice-President
Joined: Mar 2008
dmbrandon passed a Tournament Host Certification test.dmbrandon rooted the Green Bay Packers to their fourth Super Bowl win, Favre or no Favre.dmbrandon did something funny.dmbrandon impressed a staff member by doing something smart.dmbrandon is connected in the Six Degrees of Smash web.dmbrandon is actually a guy pretending to be a girl.dmbrandon wrote a blog entry that was featured on the All is Brawl front page!

I already made a lot getting it banned in NJ. It's not beatable.
#139
3:23 PM Jun 9 2009 2009
MuraRengan
Featured Blogger
Joined: Mar 2008
MuraRengan did something funny.MuraRengan helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.MuraRengan wrote a blog entry that was featured on the All is Brawl front page!

I want to post about this, but I keep seeing the same idiotic post over and over again, and it appears as if the thread keeps regressing back to arguing a point that has been made pages ago because someone posted "hur hur, planking isn't broken because you're stupid if you approach the guy on the ledge, hur hur" . It's like half the users in this thread have never even discussed this before.

"People who say all you need is love are crazy. All you really need in life is Captain Falcon." - joenopride
#140
4:09 PM Jun 9 2009 2009
Umbre
Transcendent Priority
Joined: May 2008
Umbre is an All is Brawl super moderator.Umbre has provided valuable testing services for the All is Brawl website.Umbre creates imbalance with the power of the sword.Umbre keeps people entertained by hosting fun events.Umbre positively represents All is Brawl and actively brings new users to the site.Umbre has written an exemplary guide on the All is Brawl forum.Umbre made significant contributions to all areas of All is Brawl!Umbre did something funny.Umbre impressed a staff member by doing something smart.Umbre helped an All is Brawl member with a problem.Umbre is a member of the evil league of evil. The fly in your soup. The pebble in your shoe. The demon in your bed. The peel on which you slip. A pin in every hip. The fear that keeps you awake. And your tears are all the pay I'll ever need.Umbre regularly contributes to the All is Brawl Stadium community.

Quote (originally posted by hichez):
you technically could classify anything as a mindgame.


Mindgames are player-specific. They don't count toward arguments like this. <____< If you're at a higher % or at a lower stock than the planker, why would you NOT approach? To lose? It's only logical to plank when you're at the the lower % or higher stock advantage.
Mario Kart Wii: ιm Umbre
Mario Kart 7: HD★Umbre
Page: 1 · 5 6 7 8 9 · 12
 
Quick Jump
rss